January 1, 2024

Duncan's Dr. James L. Patterson: Knight Templar

By T.S. Akers

A Sir Knight's sword produced by The Henderson Ames Co. of Kalamazoo, Michigan, which operated under that name from 1893 to 1933.

One item I seem to continue purchasing is Masonic Templar swords. Whilst I can recall at least one sword I should have bought; I tend to only acquire swords with a unique history these days. Such was the case in 2023 with a sword I purchased out of Duncan, Oklahoma. The sword in question is a typical Oklahoma regulation sword in silver for a Sir Knight below the rank of Eminent Commander. This sword belonged to an Oklahoma Mason by the name of Dr. James L. Patterson, Sr.

 
Dr. James L. Patterson in 1929.

Dr. Patterson was born at Union Star, Missouri, on the 20th of March 1884. He studied medicine at the Ensworth Central Medical College of St. Joseph, Missouri, and then conducted post-graduate study at the Rush Medical College of Chicago, Illinois.[1] Patterson came to the Oklahoma Territory in 1906, establishing his first practice at Mutual, Oklahoma. He saw service as an Army surgeon, initially with the 1st Cavalry Regiment as tensions rose due to the raids executed by Pancho Villa. When the 17th Cavalry Regiment was formed from that and other regiments in 1916, Patterson was transferred. With the 17th Cavalry, he served along the Arizona border as disputes with the IWW in the copper mining districts escalated. The 17th Cavalry remained in the southwest throughout the Great War. Upon returning from military service, Patterson made his residence at Woodward in 1919.[2]

It was at Mutual that Dr. Patterson took the degrees of Freemasonry in Mutual Lodge No. 317, becoming an Entered Apprentice on the 15th of April 1908. He was passed to the degree of Fellowcraft that July and raised to the degree of Master Mason on the 5th of August. Patterson served Mutual Lodge as Worshipful Master in 1916. Returning from the service, Patterson demitted to Woodward Lodge No. 189 in 1920.[3] Along the way, he was exalted to the degree of Royal Arch Mason in Woodward Chapter No. 72. Patterson served that chapter as High Priest in 1920.[4] He took the degrees of the Scottish Rite of Freemasonry at Guthrie in May of 1920.[5]

Dr. Patterson constructed his state of the art hospital at Duncan in 1928.

Dr. Patterson left Woodward for Elk City in 1925 to take a position at the Tisdel Hospital and then took a position at the Ruth Hospital of Duncan in 1926.[6] When the opportunity arose, Patterson purchased the Ruth Hospital in August of 1926 from Dr. G.H. Wallace.[7] Though the Ruth Hospital was just four years old in 1926, it was simply inadequate to meet the needs of Duncan. For this reason, Patterson constructed his own hospital in the fall of 1928 at a cost of $90,000. The new Patterson Hospital, located at the intersection of 10th Street and Willow Avenue, boasted fifty rooms for patients, two operating rooms, an x-ray laboratory, and a training school for nurses.[8] What was state of the art in 1928 was obsolete by 1950, at which time Patterson sold his hospital to Dr. W.R. Cheatwood. The Patterson Hospital then became the Duncan Convalescent Center.[9]

Dr. Patterson married Mary Ward of Woodward in 1908 and the family appears to have enjoyed an active social life in Duncan.[10] Their home was the site of frequent parties, including a holiday musical tea on the 26th of December 1929 with nearly one hundred guests in attendance.[11] It appears that it was at Duncan that Patterson became involved with Templary, joining Duncan Commandery No. 46, which had been chartered in 1923. It does not appear that Patterson ever progressed through the officer line of Duncan Commandery.

Dr. Patterson and his wife Mary left Duncan in 1953 for California. Unfortunately, Mary passed away the following year in Santa Monica.[12] Patterson returned to Duncan at that time, and he married Mattie Kelly in 1955.[13] He continued to practice medicine in Duncan with an office in the Perkins Building on 9th Street. In June of 1964, at the age of 80, Patterson announced his retirement, though he claimed he was just “slowing down a bit.”[14] Patterson passed away the following month on the 3rd of July. He was laid to rest with his first wife Mary at the Duncan Municipal Cemetery.[15]

Detail of the etching illustrating Dr. Patterson's name on the sword's blade.


[1]  Joseph B. Thoburn & Muriel H. Wright, Oklahoma: A History of the State and its People (New York: Lewis Historical Pub. Co., 1929), 4: 665.
[2]  "Lauded for Lengthy Medical Careers," The Duncan Banner (Duncan, OK), January 30, 1963, 1.
[3]  “Patterson, James Lindley” (member profile, Grand Lodge of the State of Oklahoma).
[4]  Proceedings of the Grand Royal Arch Chapter of Oklahoma: Thirty-Second Annual Convocation (Bartlesville, OK, 1921), 94.
[5]  “Patterson, James Lindley” (member profile, Guthrie Valley of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite).
[6]  "Lauded for Lengthy Medical Careers," The Duncan Banner.
[7]  "Ruth Hospital Sold to Dr. J.L. Patterson: In Charge Since April," The Duncan Banner (Duncan, OK), August 20, 1926, 1.
[8]  Sue Horning, National Register of Historic Places Nomination Form, Patterson Hospital, NRIS No. 95001417, March 1995, Section 8, nr2_shpo.okstate.edu/pdfs/95001417.pdf.
[9]  "Lauded for Lengthy Medical Careers," The Duncan Banner.
[10]  Thoburn & Wright, Oklahoma: A History of the State and its People, 4: 665.
[11]  "Largest Social Affair of the Holiday Season Is Musical Tea Given at Dr. Patterson Home," The Duncan Banner (Duncan, OK), January 4, 1929, 7.
[12]  "Rites Held Monday for Mrs. Patterson," The Duncan Banner (Duncan, OK), September 23, 1954, 5.
[13]  "Lauded for Lengthy Medical Careers," The Duncan Banner.
[14]  "Dr. J.L. Patterson Closes His Office," The Duncan Banner (Duncan, OK), June 4, 1964, 1.
[15]  "Dr. James L Patterson Sr.," Find A Grave, accessed December 27, 2023, https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/80618263/james-l-patterson.

November 13, 2023

Freemasons Amongst the Leadership of the Confederate Indian Brigade

By T.S. Akers

It is well established that Albert Pike was a general in the Confederate Army during the American Civil War and that he was a prominent Freemason. Whilst he is the best-known Freemason who served the Confederacy in the Indian Territory, albeit briefly, he is not the sole Freemason to do so in the Indian Brigade.

 
A Civil War era image of Albert Pike.
(Courtesy of the National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution)

Albert Pike joined the Fraternity in Western Lodge No. 2 of Little Rock, Arkansas, in 1850. He was elected Sovereign Grand Commander of the Scottish Rite in 1859.[1] An attorney, Pike was sent to the Indian Territory by the Confederacy in March of 1861 to negotiate treaties of alliance with the Five Tribes.[2] He had represented the Muscogee, Chickasaw, and Choctaw Nations in legal claims against the federal government, so the headmen of the Five Tribes were familiar with Pike.[3] The treaties that Pike negotiated with the Five Tribes required each nation to raise regiments to serve the Confederacy.[4] By early 1862, he had been commissioned a brigadier general and given command of the newly formed Indian Brigade.[5]

One of the regiments of the Indian Brigade was the 1st Choctaw & Chickasaw Mounted Rifles. The regiment’s original colonel was Douglas H. Cooper. A veteran of the Mexican War, Cooper had served as a captain in the Fifth Mississippi Militia Regiment under Jefferson Davis. In 1853, then Secretary of War Davis appealed to President Franklin Pierce on Cooper’s behalf, lobbying for Cooper to be made agent for the Choctaw Nation. After the political separation of the Choctaws and Chickasaws into two nations, Cooper remained as agent for both with a new agency established at Fort Washita. He was kept on as Confederate agent to the Choctaws and Chickasaws in 1861.[6]

 
Douglas H. Cooper studied at the University of Virginia from 1832 to 1834.

Douglas H. Cooper raised the 1st Choctaw & Chickasaw Mounted Rifles following the summer of 1861 at the request of Confederate Secretary of War LeRoy P. Walker. After Albert Pike resigned his commission in late 1862, Cooper assumed command of the Indian Brigade and was made brigadier general in 1863. He was appointed Superintendent of Indian Affairs in 1865. Cooper remained an ally of the Choctaws and Chickasaws after the war, assisting in reconstruction negotiations. He died from pneumonia at Fort Washita in 1879.[7]

In no biography of Douglas H. Cooper is any mention ever made of Freemasonry. However, the proceedings of the Grand Lodge of the Indian Territory from 1877 provide a lone reference on this subject. Because the membership was so small at this time, rosters of each lodge’s membership were easily reproduced for publication. These rosters also include a listing for “Unaffiliated Masons,” that is Brethren residing within the territorial bounds of a lodge but not holding membership in that lodge. Under this heading for Caddo Lodge No. 3, there is listed one D.H. Cooper.[8] Fort Washita, roughly twenty miles from Caddo, would have certainly been within that lodge’s territorial jurisdiction. It is unknown as to when and where Cooper received the degrees of Freemasonry. He was born in Wilkinson County, Mississippi in 1815 and attended the University of Virginia before his arrival in the Indian Territory.[9]

There were numerous other men who served under Pike and Cooper who were either Freemasons during the War or became Freemasons after. The following list, comprised from notes in Charles E. Creager’s History of Freemasonry in Oklahoma and the annual proceedings of the Grand Lodge of the Indian Territory, indicates field officers who were Masons, but should not be considered exhaustive.

Staff Officers
Major Israel G. Vore, Quartermaster 

1st Creek Mounted Rifles

Col. Daniel N. McIntosh
Lieut. Col. Samuel Checote
Major James M. McHenry

1st Choctaw Mounted Rifles

Col. Simpson N. Folsom

1st Choctaw & Chickasaw Mounted Rifles

Col. Tandy Walker

1st Battalion Chickasaw Cavalry

Major L.M. Reynolds

1st Regiment Seminole Mounted Volunteers

Col. John Jumper

1st Cherokee Mounted Rifles

Col. Stand Watie (later Brig. Gen.)
Lieut. Col. William P. Ross
Major Elias C. Boudinot
 
2nd Cherokee Mounted Rifles
Col. William P. Adair
Lieut. Col. Oliver Hazard Perry Brewer 
Major John S. Vann
 
 
Headstone of Stand Watie, bearing the Keystone of Royal Arch Masonry. Watie was a member of Northwestern Lodge No. 36 at Maysville, Arkansas. He is buried in the Polson Cemetery of Delaware County.


[1]  James T. Tresner II, Albert Pike: The Man Beyond the Monument (New York: M. Evans and Company, 1995), 236-237.
[2]  LeRoy H. Fischer and Jerry Gill, Confederate Indian Forces Outside of Indian Territory (Oklahoma City: Oklahoma Historical Society, 1969), 1.
[3]  Joy Porter, Native American Freemasonry: Associationalism and Performance in America (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2011), 217.
[4]  Mary Jane Ward, When the Wolf Came: The Civil War and the Indian Territory (Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Press, 2013), 54.
[5]  Roy A. Clifford, “The Indian Regiments in the Battle of Pea Ridge,” The Chronicles of Oklahoma 25, no. 4 (1947): 315.
[6]  Corie Delashaw, "Cooper, Douglas Hancock (1815-1879)," The Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture, accessed November 8, 2023, https://www.okhistory.org/publications/enc/entry.php?entry=CO051.
[7]  Delashaw.
[8]  Proceedings of the M.: W.: Grand Lodge A.F. & A.M. of the Indian Territory: Third Annual Communication (Vinita, Cherokee Nation, 1877), 22.
[9]  Delashaw.